Bredonborough.

Posted by Robert Fripp
8 Mar 2012
Thursday, March 8, 2012

14.35

Rising at 06.46 and over the road to World HQ I…

8mar1c.jpg

II...

8mar2c.jpg

… for morning reading I…

8mar3c.jpg

II...

8mar4c.jpg

Onto computing.

11.56    Paper organizing in the Home Study.

14.44    On the DGM Guestbook…

Photos
:: Posted by hakram on February 29, 2012
Please do remember, Mr. Fripp, when fans snap your picture, we are just excited to see you. It is we, the fans, who put you where you are. We, so-to-speak, fund you. I went to an Allan Holdsworth concert. I snapped pictures, talked with him, shook his hand, etc. I even recorded the concert. I was treated with respect. It was a nice experience. I felt removed and distant when I saw you and Belew opening for Porcupine Tree in Boston a few years back.
I’m sure it’s annoying to be mobbed all the time, but that’s the price of fame. I would think that you’d be a little more grateful and gracious towards your fans.  We do, after all, put food on your table.  A couple of old sayings come to mind: Don’t criticize your fans with your mouth full and/or don’t bite the hand that feeds you.
Disillusionally Yours, Mark Holmes

There are precedents for this posting, and responses to it, over many years (please see the ET and DGM archives); including my doubt that posts this dopey and publicly-presented are for real. I’m not sure whether the aim in posting is to provide an easy target for other Guestbookers / myself to comment on how dopey the (purportedly serious) comments are. However, on the assumption that Mr. Holmes comments are as they appear, prima facie…

MH:    Please do remember, Mr. Fripp, when fans snap your picture, we are just excited to see you.

HRVL:    When WillyFred is excited, he pisses on my feet. So when I’m excited, I can do the same to fans, my excitement a sufficient justification?

Debating with anyone who argues that uncontrollable urges are sufficient explanation for uncontrollable behaviour, is not likely to be profitable. Lets hear it for Reason and the Enlightenment!

MH:    It is we, the fans, who put you where you are

HRVL:    Yes, this is very true: I am retired from public performance.

MH:    We, so-to-speak, fund you

HRVL:    More accurately, you funded management, record companies, promoters and agents, and all their employees (not including roadies, engineers, drivers and cars, sound and light companies, tour ‘bus operators, airlines); all of whom passéd on a small proportion to the band/s (and sometimes not) of which I received a proportion in turn, usually between 15-25%. On a solo SoundScape outing, I was usually given 100% of the tab; no proportion of which was passed on to Mr. Holmes, nor to any other excitable fans with consumer rights.

DGM/KC catalogue income is professionally-successful (ie it supports a living but not a retirement-plan), larger than when Virgin was the record company, and proportionally much-much larger than the Grief that was E. But currently record-income (therefore also publishing income) is extremely-prejudiced and negatively-impacted by file-sharing and piracy. Licensing income, such as with Mr. West’s Power, suggests that reliance on record income per se, and therefore reliance on the passions of fans such as Mr. Holmes, is both something of the past (for the non-star working player) and in any case, for several reasons, a folly.

As the son of a small provincial estate agent, my personal wealth is based mainly on the distortions in the UK property market. As the son of a Welsh-miner’s daughter, I never believed that anyone would support me in my old age, middle age, nor any age at all. Hence a work ethic, and savings in the form of a personal pension, does more to support me in my post-mature years than Mr. Holmes with an army of his friends and family members, on a good year or ten.

Mr. Holmes claims that our relationship is based on commerce; and, as a recipient of Mr. Holmes patronage, he has rights to make demands of me, personally and professionally, in any form he chooses to exert; even where this goes directly against my publicly (and frequently) expressed contrary-views. But, if we are not both parties to an agreement, obviously, there is no agreement between us.

Where we demand rights and deny obligations, we assert Entitlement. We have rights where we accept matching obligations. It follows that we may claim Consumer Rights only to the extent that we recognize a consensual professional-relationship, with matching rights and obligations. Fripp as Working Player is obliged, for example, to turn up at a performance and discharge his function at least competently, hopefully honourably. In return, Mr. Holmes and his kin may enter the venue, stand or take a seat, and listen. It is hoped that the performer is reliable in discharging his function, and that the audient is receptive; which does not imply sitting quietly with tight lips, unmoving. Mutual courtesy is a hope, and an aspiration for some.

Where these professional rights are extended on one side without consent by the other - performer taking-advantage of audients, audient making unilateral demands of performer - difficulties arise that often become problematical. Mr. Holmes’ rude post, with its one-sided audient-assumptions-of-consumer -Entitlement, is an example.

There is an entirely different qualitative-relationship possible between artist and audience, to that as indicated by Mr. Holmes; one not mediated by commerce. Here, it is a required of the artist that they are True. For the relationship to come to life, there is also a requirement of the audience; part of which is that the audience lets go of its expectations and demands, and enters the available Moment: which has never been here before, although it is eternal. This is unlikely without practice and, most likely, also training. Demands such as those of Mr. Holmes have lethal effect on qualitative engagement, and show how easy it is to bring about the poverty of so much performance in contemporary culture.

MH:    I went to an Allan Holdsworth concert. I snapped pictures, talked with him, shook his hand, etc. I even recorded the concert. I was treated with respect. It was a nice experience.

HRVL:    It is a case for celebration, that Allan has a new friend for life. And Allan respects Mr. Holmes. I expect he had a nice time, too.

MH: I felt removed and distant when I saw you and Belew opening for
Porcupine Tree in Boston a few years back.

RHVL:    You should have come backstage and had a beer with us.

MH:    I’m sure it’s annoying to be mobbed all the time, but that’s the price of fame.

RHVL:    I’ve never been part of mobbing-all-the-time, but have been subject to ongoing, excessive and intrusive demands at public appearance for over three decades. (This is not the time to discuss the shifts in performer-audience relationship since 1967). But the solitary, determined fan is often more difficult to engage than several fans and enthusiasts together; where there is more likelihood of at least one person being available to manners, reason, even courtesy. Mr. Holmes provides a good case of why fame is not something I have much exerted myself to achieve.

MH:    I would think that you’d be a little more grateful and gracious towards your fans.

URHVL:    But then, Mr. Holmes has not been in my position; so has no experience on which to ground his thinking. True, Mr. Holmes’ sense of Entitlement and demand for attention does not give rise in me to a spontaneous feeling of gratitude.

Grace is a wonderful thing. More accurately, not a thing at all: a quality that moves between and among us all. But, if our head is placed where Entitlement lives, even were Grace to come up and bite us on the butt, we’d probably not notice. But if we did, we’d heave the right to take Its picture and ask for an autograph.

MH:    We do, after all, put food on your table.
URHVL:    Which was then spat upon.

MH:    A couple of old sayings come to mind: Don’t criticize your fans with your mouth full…

URHVL:    Full of crumbs.

MH:    … and/or don’t bite the hand that feeds you.

URHVL:    Were Mr. Holmes to extend a hand of generosity, who knows what response he might receive in return?

MH:    Disillusionally Yours…

URHVL:    Please, be disillusioned. Please also, embrace what is available: which may not be quite what we expect it to be, and might be even richer by far than anything we expected. But, it will not be what we did expect.

Meanwhile, I continue to pay off a largish-mortgage. Mr. Holmes should clearly give me more money.

17.13    An afternoon of paper. To the Piddle and a little sorting of stuff at Barbara’s cottage…

8mar5c.jpg

19.59    Evening shopping. Dribble.

8mar6c.jpg









Popular Posts

A Tale of Two Concerts
David Singleton
19 May 2025
Apologia Pro Vita Sua
Robert Fripp
8 Nov 2024
Exposure to Public Ridicule
David Singleton
1 May 2025
What Is A Question?
Robert Fripp
23 Mar 2025
Motel Modesto, San Luis Obispo.
Robert Fripp
28 Feb 2024

Related Posts
Casa Stella Maris, Caorle, Italy.
Robert Fripp
10 May 2013
Bredonborough.
Robert Fripp
7 May 2020
Bredonborough.           
Robert Fripp
30 Jun 2020
Bredonborough.
Robert Fripp
11 Jan 2009
Bredonborough.
Robert Fripp
23 May 2019
Just For You
ARTICLES

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

MORE

Giles, Giles & Fripp New Editions.

The Cheerful Insanity of Giles, Giles and Fripp (The Songs),...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

MORE

Happy Birthday Robert!

King Crimson's guitarist turns 79 today. To mark the occasio...

MORE

Elemental Mixing Underway

New music discovered! Lizard gets the Elemental Mix treatmen...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

MORE

Stormy takes apart FraKctured

This month Mr Stormy throws the spotlight on Robert, Adrian...

MORE

Toyah and Robert's Weekend.

Catch up with Toyah and Robert's latest weekend on YouTube.

MORE

Red Elemental Mixes

David Singleton's alternative look at the Red album now avai...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Easter Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Easter Weekend

MORE

The Academy of Music, New York, 1972.

Going live today, two shows from the same day in New York Ci...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

MORE

Creating the Larks print.

Here’s a look behind the scenes at the making of the Larks’...

MORE

Queen Elizabeth Hall Soundscapes

It’s been a 29 year wait but finally we can now hear the res...

MORE

Cruise lineup

The 2025 Cruise To The Edge has concluded. Here's a great ph...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Upbeat Moments & Sunday Lunch

MORE

Hanging Around With The Stranglers in 1980

On this day 45 years ago on April 4, 1980 Robert Fripp appea...

MORE

Larks’ Tongues silkscreen print.

The famous artwork from the sleeve of Larks’ Tongues in Aspi...

MORE

Fripp's New York: Then and Now

So what did happen to all the music places from Robert’s tim...

MORE

Toyah & Robert's Weekend

Toyah & Robert's Upbeat Moments (feat. Eno) - Saturday at 19...

MORE
DIARIES

Satch Bus.

09.23

Satch Bus.

We arrived at Hotel Adeq...

MORE

Satch Bus.

10.53

Route 66 gives a route of 1535 mil...

MORE

Cabin 6020, Silja Ferry >Stockholm.

16.21

Cabin 6020, Silja Ferry >Stockholm.

...

MORE

Satch Bus.

10.29

Bags at 09.30, lobby 10.00, set off for Got...

MORE

Satch Bus, outside venue, Copenhagen.

24.47

An experientially long overnight drive, inc...

MORE

Hotel Pricey And The Staff Are Superb, Amsterdam.

10.47

Breakfast this morning with Joe alone. He w...

MORE

Hotel It-Is-Almost Posh, Amsterdam.

09.10

Into the breakfast room at 06.30 for a quie...

MORE

The Basement, Chateau Belew.

10.28

The Basement, Chateau Belew.

The su...

MORE

The Basement, Chateau Belew.

05.30

One proper response to being alive is joy....

MORE

The Basement, Chateau Belewbeloid.

16.41

The event of the day: Martha Belew is 31 to...

MORE

Los Molinos.

07.23

Rising at 05.52, or 04.52 UK & body tim...

MORE

Crimson Tourbus, Outside Hotel Acceptable, Phoenix.

01.00

Crimson Tourbus, Outside Hotel Acceptable,...

MORE

#504, Hotel Quite Acceptable, Vancouver.

00.15

A supportive & generous audience and wh...

MORE

Hotel Quite Acceptable, Vancouver.

11.03

The weather is changeable, a blue sky rapid...

MORE

Hotel Quite Acceptable, Vancouver.

23.57

We arrived at Denver International Airport,...

MORE

Hotel Quite Acceptable, Denver.

10.42

The sun is shining, the sky is mostly blue,...

MORE

Hotel Quite Acceptable, Denver.

20.04

Snowbound in Denver. Rising at 08.30, a not...

MORE

Room Most Acceptable, Hotel Quite Acceptable.

11.00

Driving snow is blowing past on the other s...

MORE

Hotel Quite Acceptable, Denver.

23.15

And with free Ethernet access, too. A call...

MORE

Mobile HQ, Crimbus.

12.47

We left our hotel punctually at noon and ar...

MORE
DOWNLOADS

Paris

Robert Fripp
Olympia
13 Oct 2009

MORE

Soda Club

Robert Fripp
Club Soda
19 Jan 1998

MORE

TRAX

The League Of Gentlemen
Trax
21 Jul 1980

MORE

National Art Center Ottawa

Robert Fripp
National Art Center Studio
13 Aug 1979

MORE

Robson Square Theatre

Robert Fripp
Robson Square Theatre
6 Aug 1979

MORE

Decade

The League Of Gentlemen
Decade
5 Jul 1980

MORE

Cafe Campus

Robert Fripp
Cafe Campus
16 Aug 1979

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 11

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
10 Jul 2020

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 37 - Time (Amsterdam 12 Oct 2009)

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
8 Jan 2021

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 38 - Elegy Pt I (Hannover 15 Oct 2009)

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
15 Jan 2021

MORE

Pat And Robert Zoned

King Crimson
DGM Sound World I
25 Sep 2023

MORE

Bathurst Street Theatre

Robert Fripp
Bathurst Street Theatre
12 Aug 1979

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 18

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
28 Aug 2020

MORE

Bogart's

The League Of Gentlemen
Bogart's
14 Jul 1980

MORE

Rough Trade Records London

Robert Fripp
Rough Trade Records
19 Jul 1985

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 39 - Elegy Pt II (Hannover 15 Oct 2009)

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
22 Jan 2021

MORE

The Painted Bride

Robert Fripp
The Painted Bride
22 Nov 1998

MORE

KC 50 The Light of Day

King Crimson
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
17 May 2019

MORE

Music For Quiet Moments 19

Robert Fripp
DGMHQ Soundworld 1
4 Sep 2020

MORE

Forte Belvedere

Robert Fripp
Forte Belvedere
26 Jun 2006

MORE
ARTISTS

Robert Fripp

MORE
PHOTO GALLERY